RSS
GRECO report on Romania: little progress in corruption prevention in respect of MPs, judges and prosecutors
In a report published today ( Thursday, January 18), the Council of Europe’s anti-corruption body (GRECO) concludes that Romania has made very limited progress to implement its recommendations to prevent and combat corruption in respect of members of parliament, judges and prosecutors.
GRECO points out that Romania has only fully complied with two of the thirteen recommendations contained in a full evaluation published in 2016. Seven recommendations have not been implemented and another four only partly implemented.
The report notes that the main initiative taken in Romania with regard to MPs is the adoption of a code of conduct in October 2017 aiming to regulate gifts and other benefits, and the management of conflicts of interest. Despite this positive development, GRECO points out that the broad wording of the code and inconsistent rules for its enforcement prevent it from providing a fully satisfactory framework.
GRECO considers that Romania has not yet given proper consideration to improving the National Integrity Agency (NIA) performance in controlling MPs’ declarations of assets and interests, although its working methods and data processing capabilities have been improved. GRECO also calls for improving the implementation in practice of NIA’s decisions and sanctions on incompatibilities and conflicts of interest.
The legislative process remains an area of particular concern for GRECO given the persisting controversies and allegations of improper consultation, the excessive use of expedited procedure, and the lack of transparency.
As regards reforms relating to judges and prosecutors, GRECO observes the same limited decisive action. Measures to make the justice system more responsive to integrity risks are at an early stage. GRECO stresses that the Supreme Council of Magistracy (SCM) and the Judicial Inspectorate should play a more active role in terms of analysis, information and advice. Measures are also needed to reinforce the role and effectiveness of those performing managerial functions at courts and prosecution services.
GRECO also regrets the absence of tangible action to ensure that the appointment and revocation for the most senior prosecutorial functions are based on a transparent process based on objective criteria, and stresses the need for the SCM to play a stronger role in this procedure. 2017 was marked by a number of proposals and counterproposals concerning appointments, the disciplinary procedure and other aspects, some of which were perceived as an attempt to undermine the independence of the judiciary.
The report was adopted on 8 December 2017 during a plenary meeting in which GRECO also decided to carry out an ad hoc urgent evaluation of three draft laws concerning the judiciary registered for adoption by Parliament on 31 October using the expedited procedure. GRECO was not able to assess this draft legislation in the report published today because of its recent drafting. The ad hoc report currently in preparation will be discussed and eventually adopted by GRECO at its 19-23 March plenary meeting.
GRECO has requested the Romanian authorities to report back on the implementation of the pending recommendations by 31 December 2018.
PG standpoint after GRECO report: Amendments to Justice Laws contain mismatches and gaps
The General Prosecutor's Office argues in a standpoint regarding the Group of States against Corruption (GRECO) report that the amendments brought to the Justice Laws contain mismatches and gaps and don't induce predictability and stability in the judicial system, with negative consequences in respect to Justice independence and progresses recorded over the past years.
"The leadership of the Public Ministry reconfirms the position constantly expressed in respect to the legislative process of amending the Justice Laws, a process which didn't observe the efficiency and transparency standards, eluding the possibility of a real and constructive debate, without taking into account the negative opinion of the Superior Council of Magistrates [CSM] and that of the magistrate body and civil society. Furthermore, referring to the conclusions of the GRECO report, the Public Ministry reveals that the legislative amendments were not based on an impact study, containing mismatches and gaps and don't induce predictability and stability in the judicial system of Romania, with negative consequences in respect to Justice independence and progresses recorded over the past years," a release of the General Prosecutor's Office published on Thursday informs.
Prosecutor General Augustin Lazar: We will remain consistent in defending rule of law
Prosecutor General Augustin Lazar on Thursday, after GRECO published a report showing that Romania only made limited progress in what concerns the implementation of the recommendations on prevention and fight against corruption, gave assurance that the Public Ministry will remain consistent in defending the rule of law and the European justice laws.
When asked, upon his exit from the Supreme Council of Magistrates (CSM) meeting, what was his opinion about the report of the Group of States against Corruption (GRECO), Augustin Lazar said: "What I saw was that the activity of the Public Ministry was very much appreciated in this report and I would like to assure you that we will remain consistent in defending the rule of law, the justice laws and the European justice laws."